34 comments

  • tito 9 hours ago
    One unintended side effect of the removal of sulfur from shipping fuels is a drastic reduction in cloud cover over the ocean. This is estimated to have doubled global warming in the 2020s (!).

    I’m exploring how to cleanly re-create those lost clouds over the ocean. Fuel additives, spraying sea salt into clouds, modifying ship routing. If this is up your alley hit reply.

    • smartmic 8 hours ago
      Good intentions, but I would like to see a balanced discussion involving also the risks of geoengineering. It is always delicate if we interfere with a system we have not yet fully understood.

      https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Geoengineering

      • andrewvc 7 hours ago
        I wish we could afford to be very circumspect about geo engineering. There’s been too much warming to be slow about it.

        If reduction alone was an effective strategy we wouldn’t be where we are today.

        • chriswarbo 3 hours ago
          The main problem with geoengineering is not the unintended consequences, the unknown unknowns, etc. It's that it would require massive, coordinated effort.

          The reason I say that's the main problem, is because that's also the main problem with reducing fossil fuel usage.

          It's fun to debate the technical details of geoengineering (solar shades, atmospheric aerosols, enhanced weathering, etc.), in the same way that it's fun to debate the technical details of carbon reduction (energy storage methods, approaches to electrical transmission, remote work, land use, etc.).

          But none of that really matters if we, collectively, don't actually do anything! It's not as fun as comparing scifi fantasies, but the problem we need to solve is that of getting humanity to actually do something, at scale, which is collectively acknowledged as necessary yet is not immediately/individually profitable.

          If we could solve that, then we could do geoengineering; but in such a world, we might not need to, because we could also do carbon reduction, plus a bunch of other stuff!

          However, if we can't solve that, then geoengineering is an illusion.

          It's a grass-is-greener fallacy: what makes any geoengineering project seem remotely feasible, in a world where we can't even coordinate on the obviously-a-good-idea stuff?

          • ACCount39 2 hours ago
            Reduction is far, far, far worse on the "coordinated effort" front.

            Geoengineering can be carried out by a single country unilaterally. That's the geoengineering edge.

            Emissions have to be solved by every major country, and in coordination - otherwise, economics favor whoever neglects to do it. That's a coordination task orders of magnitude more severe. If your argument against geoengineering is "coordination", then you should be forsaking "emission reduction driven by political action" ten times over. Same goes for "carbon capture at scale."

            The only tool that leaves you with is "emission reduction driven by economic forces." Which may well be sufficient. But I'd rather not leave tools on the table.

            • nostrademons 2 hours ago
              I mean, I can tell you how the world is going to solve global warming. WW3. It requires zero coordination between countries; indeed, it is what you get by default when countries cannot coordinate. Likely global temperatures are going to be lower in 2050 than they are now, but they'll be that way because of a nuclear holocaust that takes us down to 1-2B people.

              This has plusses and minuses, but mostly minuses. It is less invasive to the rest of the world's ecosystems than either continued global warming or solar geoengineering with sulfur compounds. Most of the damage is confined to humanity, along with making a few areas that were already ecological wastelands uninhabitable (though interestingly, that has improved biodiversity in the Chernobyl Exclusion Area and North Korean DMZ). The downside is, of course, that 75-90% of us will be dead and whatever modern technologically-advanced society we have will collapse.

              • ACCount39 2 hours ago
                Utter nonsense. Historically, "cannot coordinate" has not lead to WW3 for many decades - including through periods of extreme tensions between major superpowers.

                The MAD nuclear standoff means that every country stands to lose a lot and gain very little by pulling the trigger. If starting a nuclear war is lose-lose for every actor, war can be prevented with low coordination burden, as long as the decision-making remains anywhere near "rational self-interest."

                • nostrademons 1 hour ago
                  The game theory behind MAD has two major preconditions behind it:

                  1) There are not so many nuclear-armed states that one country can launch an attack and have enough country blamed for it. Likewise, there are not so many nuclear-armed states that one country might launch nukes by accident or irrationality.

                  2) All nuclear armed states have a future, i.e. there is no nuclear-armed power that is facing an existential threat other than nuclear weapons.

                  #1 is the wisdom behind nuclear non-proliferation, and why all nuclear-armed powers do everything they can to prevent other states or non-state actors (like terrorist groups) from getting nuclear weapons. If there is ever a situation where a suitcase nuke goes off in Washington or Moscow and they aren't sure who did it, the world ends. The set of nuclear-armed powers initially started with the 5 members of the UN Permanent Security Counsel and since then has expanded by Israel, India, Pakistan, and North Korea, with Iran being widely suspected of being close. You see similar examples of cartel-collapse (another MAD situation, with lower stakes) when the number of participants reaches about 10 - notably, one mechanism by which OPEC prices often collapse is when smaller member states secretly overproduce and Saudi Arabia has to cut to make up the difference. Another mechanism is when new firms enter the market without any incentive to maintain the existing detente (eg. the U.S. entering the oil market with the fracking boom of the early 2010s, or Facebook blowing up the high tech wage-fixing cartel by poaching everybody's employees with generous stock grants).

                  #2 follows from the finite/infinite game distinction. As long as the payoff for launching nukes is destruction of your state, there's a strong incentive not to do it. But if your state is gone anyway, and launching a war of aggression gives you a chance of not dying, the incentives flip. A (non-nuclear, but business) example of this was the patent detente among major tech companies in 2010, "and then Nokia launched the missiles". They were facing bankruptcy anyway, launching a bunch of patent troll lawsuits gave them a potential way out, and if everybody else retaliated, the worst that would happen is they go bankrupt, which was happening anyway.

                  I've heard a number of geopolitical analysts speculate that the Russia/Ukraine war was driven by exactly this: Russia's terrible demographics following the post-Soviet collapse, compounded by the death toll from COVID, meant that they will no longer have the capacity to wage war as an advanced industrialized power within 5-10 years, and so it was now or never. Climate change is another very obvious trigger for why a state may end up default-dead and hence have nothing to lose from starting WW3.

          • tito 22 minutes ago
            When you say massive coordinated effort, say more about that. There’s definitely a spectrum of different solutions. Some of them look like things humanity has built in the past. Others look like things we haven’t ever built before. Curious what you’re seeing out there.
          • LightBug1 3 hours ago
            We've been geoengineering and not giving a shit about unintended consequences for the last 200 years.

            Why change the habit of a species? Just saying.

            Clutching at our pearls at this stage just seems a bit ... ridiculous considering what's gone on.

            • sophacles 3 hours ago
              So your point is "lets just keep doing the same things that got us into this mess in the first place, surely we can solve it that way!"?
              • Scramblejams 20 minutes ago
                Saying you want to actively geoengineer your way out of a problem isn't "the same things" as having passively geoengineered your way into a problem.

                The way I see it, if we want to inhabit this planet for the next several hundred thousand years, eventually natural variations will arrive that swamp anything we've done in our usual passive, uncoordinated fashion. So if we want to keep living here, we're going to need to figure out how to set the world's thermostat. Might as well start working the problem now.

              • ACCount39 2 hours ago
                Yes, that's the point. The point is that humans should own the influence they have over the world, and put that influence to use.

                As opposed to trying to flinch away from it and pretend it doesn't exist. And then acting surprised when that doesn't make their influence go away - and merely makes it unguided, purposeless and often harmful.

        • capitainenemo 6 hours ago
          There's been a few interesting proposals for solar shade to block like 1.5% or so of the sun's light at the lagrange point. One using a single shield as opposed to a swarm (seems more reliable) would require like 100-200 starships to lift the mass. Probably relatively cheap in terms of geoengineering if starship actually becomes a standard lift vehicle at their targeted costs. Doesn't fix acidification, but is a lot more reversible than many geoengineering plans.
        • modo_mario 6 hours ago
          > There’s been too much warming to be slow about it.

          And yet we're still pumping up fossil fuels and this geoengineering would be used as an excuse to keep doing it. At some point we're going to feel other effects or potentially be trapped expending resources to keep the geoengineering going.

          • endymi0n 4 hours ago
            You’re right, 100%, but it’s not gonna buy us anything.

            Looking at the cold, hard numbers, geoengineering isn‘t the best option to keep the nightmare level tipping points from happening. It’s the ONLY one.

            This is a problem 200 years on the making and the numbers and the momentum is incomprehensible. We can scramble how many more teaspoons of rudder surface we can get into the water to turn the Titanic around, or we can use the same energy to put rubber on the hull.

            All we need is buy us time for 50 more years, with something reversible in far shorter time, like a solar shield.

          • masfuerte 5 hours ago
            Yes, the warming isn't the only problem. The acidification of the oceans isn't going to be halted by blocking sunlight.
          • NewJazz 6 hours ago
            Yeah I feel like we have to stop fucking things up before trying to claim that what we do is going to make things better.
        • spwa4 7 hours ago
          Anything we do is geoengineering. So in terms of outcome, choosing the outcome seems like the superior option to just letting things happen.

          What you're worried about is people looking for someone to blame ... and finding you. Politics, in other words.

          Although I'll agree with politics on one front: any form of geoengineering, including further increasing global warming, will have winners and losers. And global warming is pretty unique in that it essentially only has winners. The earth becomes greener, more fertile, and needs a lot less heat. Fixing it will ... well, it will do the opposite.

          • tito 7 hours ago
            Can I offer something here? My sense is you might have a mental model that says the changing climate is a bit like a dimmer switch. A little warmer, things seem better off, let's do it. And I'm receptive to that to a certain extent.

            But my mental model is that the stable climate we have is more like a light switch. It's not about a little warmer, it's about we go too far and switch into a chaotic climate unknown in the entirety of human existence. Even with the "big" affects we've seen so far, they're still in the "stable climate zone", haven't flipped the switch yet. Thoughts?

            • unrented7977 7 hours ago
              We are already in a chaotic climate unknown. Things are already really, really bad and they can't realistically get worse, only bad faster.

              Doing nothing is certain doom, so why not do something? We can't fuck the planet any harder than we already have.

              • ifyoubuildit 7 hours ago
                This sounds like a pretty dangerous mindset. Its already broken so why worry about breaking it worse?

                What do you mean doing nothing is certain doom?

                • unethical_ban 3 hours ago
                  It appears to me you don't think climate change is a current and worsening issue.
                  • ifyoubuildit 1 hour ago
                    I am not aware that things are so fucked that we don't have to worry about the consequences of well meaning blunders.

                    Just cause the patient's hand is broken doesn't mean you should do something that risks losing the whole arm. At least not if you think about it rationally.

                • spwa4 3 hours ago
                  That's what people are using to get elected. BUT also: doing anything at all about it (other than end capitalism, of course) is worse than certain doom.

                  Sorry, I mean to say that's the scientific consensus, in IPCC reports, ... Both of those.

              • alphawhisky 6 hours ago
                Yeah, I will spend my entire adult life trying to convince people like you to listen to the experts (me, and others who study and work with the environment). You are so wrong it's not even funny. Would you take this same stance of "we can't mess it up any more" in regards to the market? You can pretty obviously see where that is taking us. Personally, I refuse to let you liquidate polar bears at a loss, metaphorically speaking. You need to take a step back and get in touch with OUR vision here. Treat our planet like you're renting, not owning.
                • Gracana 5 hours ago
                  I don't believe you. You're not even trying to convince anyone here.
                  • alphawhisky 2 hours ago
                    "You can't convince a man to understand something if his salary depends on him not understanding it" - Upton Sinclair
                • gruntledfangler 4 hours ago
                  > let you liquidate polar bears at a loss, metaphorically speaking

                  What on Earth are you on about?

                  • alphawhisky 2 hours ago
                    There is no amount of global warming that is "safe", and it has been proven to be caused by human activity to a large extent. Even if society adjusts to global warming, our environment will not. Species like polar bears will be the ones to pay the price for our actions. I think that outcome is detestable.
              • chriswarbo 4 hours ago
                > Things are already really, really bad and they can't realistically get worse

                Every other planet we know of is a counterexample to this argument.

                The Earth is a paradise, but it's fragile; and things can get SO MUCH worse.

              • ceejayoz 5 hours ago
                > Doing nothing is certain doom, so why not do something?

                https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Politician%27s_syllogism

          • TFNA 6 hours ago
            Would you consider millions of people forced from lowlands like in Bangladesh winners? Are the populations of other countries that have to take in refugee swells winners?
            • foxglacier 4 hours ago
              I looked into this once and found that population density in Bangladesh is increasing faster due to population growth than sea level rise. Why isn't that a problem? Millions of people forced from lowlands by their own mothers? Well perhaps it's not a problem and people moving because of overcrowding is normal and OK.
            • spwa4 3 hours ago
              Just to show how ridiculous one of these comments is. The point is that people shout this sort of thing out without even checking. Bangladesh itself has barely changed. It's gotten 1 to 1.5 degrees warmer. But given the political situation, despite the changes since, it doesn't make much sense to talk about Bangladesh without considering at least the entire Ganges valley, the vast majority of which is in India, plus in 1850 there was no separation, so let's just consider all of India.

              One notable change to Bangladesh is that the southern desert has withdrawn ... literally to zero, there isn't a square centimeter of desert left, but it wasn't huge to begin with, plus it wasn't entirely in what is today Bangladesh.

              In 1850, before global warming (or at least the human part), probably 40% of India was a desert, versus 13% now. And India is the size of Western Europe right. The area that became agricultural land and forest because of global warming is about the size of France PLUS the size of Germany.

              Additionally, global warming is increasing the water available to Bangladesh, not decreasing it as you might expect. But as you point out, yes, there are winners and losers. Although, frankly, a water infrastructure project (that needs to be done regardless of global warming or not) could fix the lowlands problem AND help the water shortage in other parts of the country. That should be a priority, but they won't do it.

              But yes, in summary, up to this point, I would consider the people of Bangladesh, and especially all of India overall winners in global warming. Very big winners in fact.

              That won't stay that way: water shortages in the Ganges valley will get worse and worse over the next century (whether or not global warming continues, just for slightly different reasons in each case). And the economics of pumping water, sorry, means half to two thirds of those people have to leave. But the problem hasn't really taken off yet. It's a rounding error at the moment.

              I do understand that past performance is no guarantee of future success and there are regions of India (not Bangladesh btw) that will become difficult to inhabit at over 2 degree warming. On the one hand I'd say they have plenty of warning, but I don't believe for one second they'll do anything about it.

              The point is that change is change. Global warming has so far had very few victims (and yes "so far" is probably justified in that sentence). Really. But not zero. Absolutely. Not zero.

              • TFNA 1 hour ago
                You rather missed the point. Danger to Bangladesh is no dearth of water but in fact the opposite: flooding through sea-level rise.
                • spwa4 1 hour ago
                  Nope it's both. And do you have any doubts about the ability of bad governance to create water shortages in a river delta that's slowly flooding?

                  https://wsup.com/media-centre/news/what-bangladeshs-groundwa...

                  Among other considerable problems they caused they pumped so much water sea water is spreading inland through the ground and poisoning and contaminating the soil (apparently this doesn't just introduce salt, but also dangerous bacteria and viruses).

          • dimes 7 hours ago
            Of course choosing the outcome is better than not choosing the outcome. No one disputes that. The question is, can you accurately choose the outcome without unintended side effects?
            • keyringlight 5 hours ago
              Then you're getting into philosophy and consequentialism. I doubt anyone can predict what will happen with any option that will satisfy everyone, there will always be bad consequences for some including deliberately staying with the status quo or analysis paralysis to the same effect.
            • spwa4 1 hour ago
              Yeah. Maybe it's just me but it certainly looks like everyone's disputing that ...

              Active measures to control (ie. choose) the outcome are known as geoengineering. Read up on it.

          • alphawhisky 6 hours ago
            Hey Environmental Engineer (P.E.) here. That's a crazy thing to claim. Our energy needs for cooling just surpassed our energy needs for heating. Water chemistry and the water cycle on Earth (the carbonate cycle, wind/ocean currents, rainfall) all rely on our existing delicate balance and temperature. Our goal should never be to launch ourselves into further climate change. We know far too little, and simpletons like you convince everyone else that we don't need more money going into research.
            • DANmode 4 hours ago
              > Our energy needs for cooling just surpassed our energy needs for heating.

              This is interesting in itself.

              I wonder what this data looks like if you only took data from habitable places, e.g. you could grow grass naturally for a portion of the year.

              Lots of nonsensical places to live are being propped up by cheap utilities right now…

          • throw-the-towel 5 hours ago
            > The earth becomes greener, more fertile

            The farms suffering from drought would like a word with you.

          • darkwater 6 hours ago
            > And global warming is pretty unique in that it essentially only has winners. The earth becomes greener, more fertile, and needs a lot less heat.

            Wait, what? Are you seriously saying this?

          • hackeman300 7 hours ago
            Only winners? What about the extreme heatwaves and stronger hurricanes due to the warmer oceans?
          • samudrijan 5 hours ago
            [flagged]
        • pif 2 hours ago
          > There’s been too much warming to be slow about it.

          Exactly! We must learn to cope with it. Without stopping to look for a solution that does not impact the economy negatively.

        • DFHippie 4 hours ago
          > If reduction alone was an effective strategy we wouldn’t be where we are today.

          Any strategy which you fail to apply is going to be ineffective.

        • bshepard 6 hours ago
          [flagged]
          • ImPostingOnHN 5 hours ago
            > Is there really too much warming or is there a power grab by alarmist scientists and enemies of civilization?

            The first one.

            Thank you for asking, it shows that you know what you don't know, and that are willing to learn. Wish more people were like that.

            Now that you have the answer, you can go forth today with new knowledge and ponder new possibilities.

            • bshepard 5 hours ago
              I suspect you may be simplifying excessively.
              • ImPostingOnHN 4 hours ago
                I welcome your suspicions! Suspect away! I'm glad we have the freedom to suspect any random thing that crosses our mind.

                At least you aren't asking questions about which your mind is already made up, pretending to be interested in learning, but with an actual intention to argue with the people who give you the correct answers, like some sort of bad-faith internet debater.

          • mschuster91 6 hours ago
            > Is there really too much warming or is there a power grab by alarmist scientists and enemies of civilization?

            There really is too much warming. We have in fact known that humanity's CO2 emissions will be dangerous for well, well over a century but haven't done much in mitigation efforts ever since for much too long, especially "thanks" to fossil fuel corporations investing a lot of money into deflection such as the "co2 footprint" [2].

            The problem is, with each year we wait in reducing carbon emissions, we have to do much more work in the future. Carbon dioxide (and other climate gases) are like compounding interest in debt, the longer you wait the more you gotta pay in the end.

            [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/History_of_climate_change_scie...

            [2] https://www.theguardian.com/commentisfree/2021/aug/23/big-oi...

          • simonw 6 hours ago
            Yeah, those nefarious scientists and their constant grabs for power!

            (Do people really believe that? Is this based on watching too many Bond films?)

            • bshepard 5 hours ago
              Scientists are human and seek power and influence like all of us. This is not about being a Bond villain but polluting the public discourse with alarmism.
            • anticorporate 5 hours ago
              I mean, how can folks not see the massive global shift away from populism and towards evidence-based public policy over the past decade! /s
      • scarecrowbob 3 hours ago
        Much of the current discussion around geoengineering feels, to me, quite reminiscent of eugenics discussions I've read from 100 or so years ago.
      • vjvjvjvjghv 6 hours ago
        Yeah, it seems pretty crazy to attempt geoengineering while we can't even agree on how the current climate works.
        • throw-the-towel 2 hours ago
          TBH we don't know how some common medicine works, yet doctors prescribe it all the same.
        • avisser 5 hours ago
          That sounds like textbook analysis paralysis.
          • ACCount39 2 hours ago
            This. What people don't get is: inaction is not free! Inaction is not safe!

            Inaction is, on the other hand, very easy to justify. That doesn't make it a good choice.

            Acting now with imperfect understanding beats letting climate change unfold as is.

      • tito 8 hours ago
        Here here! Would love to hear about what format you would like to see this in. There’s some existing discussion I can point you to but there’s so much more to be discussed about what we do understand, and so much to be explored that we don’t understand. At the same time, warming is accelerating and inaction is having real consequences too.
        • tcptomato 8 hours ago
          what is here?
          • tito 7 hours ago
            hah, “Here, here is a common misspelling, caused by the fact that hear and here are homophones—words that sound the same but have different meanings and spellings” TIL
      • JoeAltmaier 1 hour ago
        Normal and accepted to hurtle on heedless with industrial emissions - geoengineering with no thought to the consequences.

        Somebody wants to try remediation, and instantly folks say Whoa! Not so fast!

      • Towaway69 5 hours ago
        With so many great geoengineering ideas on “saving” the planet, i wonder how the earth got so far without us and our good intentions.

        The earth seems to get along just fine without us and it keeps showing us by somehow always being the last thing standing when yet another civilisation collapses - as ours will too.

      • chris_va 5 hours ago
        I'm sorry ma'am, we cannot give your son cancer treatment because we do not fully understand how the body works.

        (disclaimer that I manage a climate research group, and this hit a nerve because we've had balanced discussions on this topic ad nauseam for the last 30+ years)

      • bell-cot 5 hours ago
        Maybe "yes" in the abstract - but was there any Geoengineering discussion about removing the sulfur, thereby altering the centuryish-long status quo?

        And as soon as a major country experiences a climate event (especially heat wave) which seriously endangers its ruling class, the gloves are going to come off - "Shut up and seed those big, reflective clouds NOW."

      • throwaway2037 8 hours ago
        China has already be doing it for more than 20 years: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Beijing_Weather_Modification_O...
        • tito 7 hours ago
          Humanity has been doing “it” since the industrial revolution to the tune of a trillion tons of excess carbon dioxide.
          • blach 6 hours ago
            Humanity has been doing “it” since we figured out large scale agriculture and gained the ability to produce widespread land use change.

            It just so happens that Beavers are the only other species capable of this kind of land use change.

            So I think for this problem it’s us and the beavers…

            • splicebot 5 hours ago
              No and no. CO2 emissions have gone up 10x since WWII. Quantity has a quality all its own. 100x doing 'it' isn't the same 'it.'

              Beavers are far from the only animal that produces land use change. But they are one of the smaller number that change it for their own benefit.

    • Timshel 7 hours ago
      Not sure where your doubling is coming from.

      https://attheu.utah.edu/research/cleaner-ship-fuel-changed-c...

      Not even clear if there was a change ...

      > It turned out that the clouds after the fuel change held more total water overall, which balanced out changes in droplet size and maintained cloud solar reflectivity, known as albedo. Had the albedo of Atlantic clouds reduced, they would have reflected less of the sun’s heat back into space, thereby warming the climate.

      • afarah1 3 hours ago
        I'm guessing from this: https://www.nature.com/articles/s43247-024-01442-3

        >In 2020, fuel regulations abruptly reduced the emission of sulfur dioxide from international shipping by about 80% and created an inadvertent geoengineering termination shock with global impact. (...) The amount of radiative forcing could lead to a doubling (or more) of the warming rate in the 2020s. (...) The warming effect is consistent with the recent observed strong warming in 2023 and expected to make the 2020s anomalously warm.

    • psp99 9 hours ago
      I have a PhD in cloud formation, so hit me up if you want to work together.
      • tito 9 hours ago
        Yes happy to email you if you share it, or ping my email in my profile
      • chuckadams 5 hours ago
        > I have a PhD in cloud formation

        Damn, I knew the AWS CF format was tricky, didn't know they had advanced degrees in it! ;)

      • DANmode 8 hours ago
        Of course you’ll tell me it’s been studied for some decades and is fine,

        but does anyone in this space take interest in public objection to (further, and continuously) altering the atmosphere and its balances/patterns?

        Is this discussed? What is the community model on this - is it like fracking, where everybody tells each other there’s no way it’s big enough to make a difference to anything?

        • tito 8 hours ago
          First off sorry about the downvotes from people. It’s a great question and sometimes downvotes even lead to the reply button disappearing.

          I don’t think this sulfur-in-shipping-fuels-creating-cloud-cover topic has been studied for decades, a lot of the research is new in just the last couple years

          Carbon dioxide annual emissions, despite years of discussion around lowering them, continue to rise. With the resulting atmospheric levels reaching levels not seen in human existence. And this shipping fuel change is (surprisingly quickly) revealing some of the impacts of that, that the warming caused by carbon emissions is much higher than previously understood.

          • DANmode 4 hours ago
            No, not the fuel thing - I mean cloud-seeding

            and other levers for environmental weather-pattern alteration (used both for vanity projects like the Olympics in China, all the way down to farming assistance and etc) that impact balances and threshold patterns in surrounding areas.

    • leoedin 9 hours ago
      My dad's involved in a project to find technical solutions to that. They're researching technologies to increase cloud cover - the core idea is a salt spray to seed clouds. I think the biggest challenge is creating small enough salt crystals with a low enough energy input.

      https://oceancooling.org/

      • tito 9 hours ago
        Haha small world! Would be great to chat with your dad. I’m doing a fellowship at a philanthropy including building a technoeconomic model for marine cloud brightening. If you’re open to it my email is in my profile.
        • trueno 8 hours ago
          damn it you guys do cool stuff, respect
    • vevoe 3 hours ago
      Just wanted to say I saw a comment from you a few months ago in a thread about this year's El Niño where you talked about what you're doing at AirMiners and mentioned Boot Up. From there, I signed up and am in the current Boot Up class and loving it! Thank you for putting that all together.
    • tito 7 hours ago
      Shoot, re-reading my comment now, it seems clearer for me to say "This is estimated to have doubled the rate of global warming in the 2020s (!).'. I could see someone reading it as saying it doubled global warming entirely, which is not accurate.
      • gosub100 7 hours ago
        So more acidic rain in exchange for less direct sunlight on the ocean? Not sure that's a better tradeoff
        • subscribed 5 hours ago
          Less energy to enter and stay with us.
    • novia 4 hours ago
      Keep in mind that cloud cover in the ocean also leads to things like hurricanes and typhoons through sufficiently wet conditions. Global warming went up, yes, but the number of extreme storms went down (contrary to the previous predictions of some climate experts)
    • dr_dshiv 8 hours ago
      I love this enormously, hit me up. At TU Delft. To demonstrate my love of clouds, see them in a realtimelapse: https://earthlove.live
      • tito 8 hours ago
        Emailed!
        • dr_dshiv 6 hours ago
          Btw (and this is a digression, I warn you)

          Cornelis Drebbel (1572-1633) is my favorite Alchemist. Not only did he create the first cybernetic system (a thermostat) and perpetual motion machine (powered by fluctuations of barometric pressure) but also the first functional submarine.

          Around 1620, witnesses saw it row under the Thames for hours.

          Robert Boyle speculated how they might refresh the air — and of course oxygen is an issue — but carbon dioxide build up is bigger.

          I suspect Drebbel used a slurry of lime as ballast to pull out the CO2. (I have a full sized replica of his sub in Amsterdam, but no I haven’t tried it yet.)

          Just in case you wanted a historical perspective on carbon sequestration!

    • nik282000 3 hours ago
      Years ago I saw a concept for huge sailing drones that would use the wind to drive them and equipment for blowing sea water up into the air to increase cloud generation. Seemed like something that would work but only with drones numbering in the thousands or tens or thousands.
    • mbo 2 hours ago
    • whazor 9 hours ago
      Makes me wonder if you could build autonomous solar/wind powered ships.

      For lots of cargo, it doesn't matter if the shipment takes extra couple months.

      We used to have a wind powered shipping industry before.

      • nkoren 9 hours ago
        I've got a friend doing exactly that: https://www.ladonrobotics.com/
      • jazzyjackson 3 hours ago
        It is a niche that might expand for those companies that want to emphasize their eco friendliness.

        The first ship in the new wave is Neoliner Origin operating between Baltimore and France

        https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Neoliner_Origin

        Then this isn’t cargo but it is a very cool solar/wind electric ship for cruising the arctic:

        https://selar.cc/pages/the-ship

        A lot of the images are renders but the ship exists and going through sea trials now

        They are both equipped with diesel engines as backup. Hopefully these two will provide valuable experience for these rigid sails.

      • thelastgallon 3 hours ago
        Better to go nuclear. Nuclear on land costs more because its construction. If its shipping, it becomes manufacturing, bringing economies of scale and rapid iterative learning.
      • pingou 7 hours ago
        If it takes 3 times more time, I imagine it costs around 3 times as much, as the ship is only able to move a third of a normal ship cargo in the same amount of time, with the same crew cost and same ship cost (or perhaps even higher cost, although you do save money on fuel).
        • whazor 5 hours ago
          Current ships have really big and complicated engines, thus needing permanent crews to maintain them.

          With solar/wind only, you would let the ship take longer. But it would be simpler and cheaper. Maybe a couple of batteries for electronics, but not for movement.

          Going fully remote via Starlink would indeed be a requirement. You manage a bigger slower fleet instead of a single ship.

      • greggsy 8 hours ago
        Colombia are innovators in the field of autonomous sea cargo.
    • DunnoKruegerSfx 9 hours ago
      Solar driven ultracsonic evaporators?
      • tito 9 hours ago
        Maybe! What’s that?
        • shagie 7 hours ago
          https://research.noaa.gov/injecting-light-reflecting-particl...

          https://www.scientificamerican.com/article/salt-spray-may-pr... (2013)

          > There are many ways to try and climate engineer the planet, but many of them are so far-fetched that scientists aren't sure if they would even be physically possible, let alone physically successful. Sea-salt climate engineering (SSCE) might be the most low-tech, and plausible, possibility.

          > In such a situation, specially designed unmanned boats would plow the seas, spraying salt water into the air. The water would evaporate and leave behind sea-salt particles, which may be lifted into the clouds, increasing their albedo, or reflecting power.

          > A study released last month in the Journal of Geophysical Research: Atmospheres used three different models to run the same SSCE scenario in which sea-salt engineering was used in the low-latitude oceans to keep top-of-atmosphere radiative forcing at the 2020 level for 50 years and was then abruptly turned off for 20 years.

          (If you want to read the study in full, https://agupubs.onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/full/10.1002/201... )

          https://www.barrierreef.org/news/explainers/what-is-cloud-br...

          https://atmos.uw.edu/faculty-and-research/marine-cloud-brigh...

          > Atmospheric scientists are still not certain just how much of a cooling effect these aerosol particles have on the climate overall. Scientists estimate that aerosols from human emissions are offsetting 0.5℃ of global warming from greenhouse gases, but they could be cooling as little as 0.2 ℃ or as much as 1.0 ℃ (Forster et al., 2021). The uncertainty in this number leads to uncertainty about how much warming to expect in the coming decades.

          > If the effect of aerosols on clouds is large, reducing aerosol pollution might significantly accelerate climate warming in the very near term. One recent paper concluded that there has already been an acceleration in global warming due to the decline in atmospheric aerosols since 2010, and projects that between now and 2040 the rate of warming may double due to this effect (Hansen et al., 2023). Recent steep reductions in particulate pollution emissions from ships that coincided with record ocean surface and global temperatures have increased interest in understanding and quantifying these effects.

    • gambiting 9 hours ago
      Ah, the aerosol masking effect[0]

      Somewhat counterintuively, if we suddenly somehow reduced our emissions to 0 overnight, the global warming would rapidly accelerate for a few years before declining.

      [0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Global_dimming

    • npongratz 7 hours ago
      So... are you looking to create a real life Terminal Shock?
    • zoeysmithe 3 hours ago
      There doesn't seem to be a consensus on this "The team estimated the specific warming effect following fuel regulation but also found that natural variability in cloud behavior makes these changes difficult to pin down."

      https://cpo.noaa.gov/the-unintended-consequences-of-reducing...

    • sandworm101 7 hours ago
      >> I’m exploring how to cleanly re-create those lost clouds over the ocean.

      But haven't we recently learned that marine algae are the primary net absorbers of CO2? cutting their sunlight therefore cannot do much good. Better than we cut sunlight over land than water. (Plants absorb CO2 but do not sequester it nearly as much as oceanic algae.)

    • 2OEH8eoCRo0 7 hours ago
      Phil Mason has been working on burning sodium that produces very fine particles of harmless baking soda. He thinks if it were retrofitted to already available passenger jets it could make a difference.

      https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ST49jDo4d-Q

    • funkytownjoe 2 hours ago
      Quit shipping shit from China around the world. Nobody has the balls to do it. Yet they want to cut back on my culture crawl with my crib boys
    • cheeze 9 hours ago
      Dummy here: Why are clouds over the ocean important?

      It seems like those clouds _shouldn't_ exist if they are caused by sulfur being pumped into the atmosphere? Why do we want them back?

      • Tarq0n 9 hours ago
        That's the naturalistic fallacy. They served a useful purpose (keeping sunlight out) even if they were artificial.
        • modo_mario 6 hours ago
          If they kept sunlight out wouldn't that prevent evaporation which would in turn contribute to cloud cover?
        • DANmode 8 hours ago
          At what cost?

          Sunlight does stuff besides create heat.

          Are you aware of fungal infections and deaths spiking recently?

      • layer8 9 hours ago
        The fact that they shouldn’t exist doesn’t contradict that they purportedly slowed global warming.
      • tito 9 hours ago
        Great question, the comments already here give a good indication. One thing I want to get better at is explaining this in a way that answers your question because there’s something really counterintuitive about all this!

        Happy for any followup questions.

        Here’s an article from MIT explaining more: https://climate.mit.edu/ask-mit/how-much-global-warming-has-...

      • pepperoni_pizza 9 hours ago
        Yes, but we also _shouldn't_ have > 400 ppm of CO2 in atmosphere. Counteracting that is good.
        • kachnuv_ocasek 9 hours ago
          It's not counteracting, though. It's only masking and delaying the effects.
          • shagie 6 hours ago
            It's changing the slope of the change to one closer to what was observed a century ago before things like the Clean Air Act addressed other issues with atmospheric pollutants and unmasked the real rate of change from global warming.

            It would give us more time to address the issues before things go catastrophically wrong with the climate that we have.

            If the argument is "we're not going to do anything anyways, might as well take our lumps with the new climate" then geo-engineering is a waste of time.

            If the argument is "we need a bit more time to address the social and political issues that decarbonization brings about and get some sanity in the larger industrialized nations", then geo-engineering helps provide that time.

            • modo_mario 6 hours ago
              >It would give us more time to address the issues before things go catastrophically wrong with the climate that we have.

              I'd predict that it would be used as an excuse to keep pumping fossil fuels for longer to increase that ppm since the urgency is dimished.

              • sacred_numbers 1 hour ago
                This response doesn't make sense in a world where solar is the fastest growing energy source. We solved climate change (cheap solar, cheap batteries, electrification, and synthetic fuels with net zero carbon) it just takes time to roll out. We are going to pump fossil fuels until the alternatives are available and cheaper than fossil fuels. There is no amount of diplomacy that would allow otherwise. Therefore, anything we can do to delay climate change is good.
      • weird-eye-issue 9 hours ago
        Arsenic is naturally occurring, why shouldn't you eat it with each meal?
      • Hikikomori 9 hours ago
        Clouds can reflect sunlight.
    • metalman 9 hours ago
      There is no credible follow up research and investigations to the extravagent claims around sulfur DIOXIDE made years ago, just cut and paste till you puke, not to mention the article is about sulfur monoxide, an even more nasty compound.

      edit: this data about cruise ships, handily omits the emmisions caused by billionare lifesyle, and rest of the 'liesure industry', and plonks respinsibility on people who are often enjoying a once in a lifetime post retirment adventure that is relentlessly promoted to them everywhere they look.

      • tito 9 hours ago
        Just so I understand, you’re saying the extravagant claims were that a) a drastic reduction in cloud cover b) accelerated global warming c) caused by lowering sulfur dioxide emissions in shipping fuels. Is it all a/b/c of those claims have no credible follow up research or some subset?
        • metalman 9 hours ago
          you catch on quick, so yes the aerosol forming particles and the proprted results are unsubstantiated, and are promoted and exagerated relentlessly, with NO DATA.
          • tito 8 hours ago
            I’m not clear where you’re saying is unsubstantiated. Is it that particles don’t form aerosols, so then the rest of what follows is unsubstantiated? I don’t think that’s what you’re saying but let me know. I linked some papers in a comment elsewhere in this thread, happy to hear comments about those articles in case you’ve read them.
            • metalman 8 hours ago
              wiki on topic, the bottom line is that SO² is marginal, and will be zero'ed out with methane, and is a non issue, but more to the point SO² emmisions are mostly land based in the first place, AND we are supposed to be talking about SO, so

              Regardless of the current strength of aerosol cooling, all future climate change scenarios project decreases in particulates and this includes the scenarios where 1.5 °C (2.7 °F) and 2 °C (3.6 °F) targets are met: their specific emission reduction targets assume the need to make up for lower dimming.[85] Since models estimate that the cooling caused by sulfates is largely equivalent to the warming caused by atmospheric methane (and since methane is a relatively short-lived greenhouse gas), it is believed that simultaneous reductions in both would effectively cancel each other out.[86] [87] Yet, in the recent years, methane concentrations had been increasing at rates exceeding their previous period of peak growth in the 1980s,[88][89] with wetland methane emissions driving much of the recent growth,[90][91] while air pollution is getting cleaned up aggressively.[92] These trends are some of the main reasons why 1.5 °C (2.7 °F) warming is now expected around 2030, as opposed to the mid-2010s estimates where it would not occur until 2040.[83]

              the rest

              https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Special:Search&se...

              • tito 8 hours ago
                Hi, the link is to Wikipedia results containing “sulphur dioxide”, not sure if there’s a specific page you meant to link.

                Agree the OP article is about SO, thanks for playing along.

                I didn’t understand SO2 being zeroed out by methane. Like one warms, one cools, they cancel eachother out? In this case humanity is removing SO2 (net = warmer) and adding methane (net = warmer) so if seems they both make things worse.

                • metalman 2 hours ago
                  SO², net cooling,but depends on the what is produced along side in the same reactions, ie: complicated. Methane, CH⁴ is a net heater.
                • 3lambda 7 hours ago
                  I respect you a lot for engaging!
              • HelloMcFly 7 hours ago
                [flagged]
          • TeMPOraL 8 hours ago
            No data, or just not enough sociopolitical commentary on your pet favorite topic, "billionaire lifestyle"?
            • metalman 2 hours ago
              actualy reluctant(ish) about 'billionare lifestyle' and am trying to think of a way to reframe what in a sense is the predictable consiquences of bieng part of a competitive hiarchical species who's ability to aquire 'needs' is far in excess of our eco systems carriying capacity, and 'blame' is a conventional way to frame the discussion
    • TacticalCoder 9 hours ago
      [flagged]
      • sdoering 8 hours ago
        > I'd like explanations and excuses from all those who want to pack us in cities

        I'd like to know who you are talking about? I have never heard of bands of eco activists rounding people up and herding them into cities and high rises like cattle.

        > who keep attacking individuals' rights to move freely using cars

        Absolutely. Those street gangs of eco activists stopping us at gun point and forcing us out of our cars are really becoming a nuissance.

        /s

        • TeMPOraL 8 hours ago
          > Absolutely. Those street gangs of eco activists stopping us at gun point and forcing us out of our cars are really becoming a nuissance.

          Like never before, we need the street fighting mathematicians and other scientists to engage these roving hordes.

  • trashb 5 hours ago
    At this point I don't see why cruise ships are still allowed, I say ban them. They are super polluting, dangerous for spreading disease and many more problems (bad treatment of the staff, a role in human trafficking, tax evasion). They are completely optional, they exist purely for entertainment/excess.

    If humanity agreed to stop all cruise ships we would safe more pollution then any other measure we are forced to make currently (which could still be done in addition). To me the fact that cruise ships are still operating proves that most governments are not interested in actually improving climate pollution.

    To me it seems like the lowest hanging fruit in the climate disaster.

    • marky1991 4 hours ago
      Doesn't this argument reduce to "all things not strictly required for life that consume resources are immoral"?

      If not, where are you drawing the fine lines?

      A critic could allege that the claim is really "all things not strictly required for life that I don't value or appreciate that consume resources are immoral".

      • trashb 4 hours ago
        no, I am saying consider banning the outliers that bring huge consequences. This is normal behavior and we do this in every part of life.

        I like cars, we ban cars from the road that pollute too much. I like racing cars, still it is illegal to race on the public road because it would be unsafe. Why shouldn't we extend the same thinking to cruise ships? Especially regarding they only provide entertainment with a clear alternative, go to a all inclusive hotel.

        Let's not pretend like banning cruise ships will lead to banning "all things not strictly required for life" like going for a walk.

        • marky1991 3 hours ago
          If your problem is polluting, shouldn't you ban polluting then?

          The cruise thing is an irrelevant detail.

          "Let's not pretend like banning cruise ships will lead to banning "all things not strictly required for life" like going for a walk."

          If that's not what you're saying then you need to explain how the analysis is wrong and what's so special about crusises morally.

          • apf6 3 hours ago
            Your logic is overly reductionist, slippery-slope, and lacking context. We already ban recreational things like the use of lead bullets for hunting, or the use of fireworks in areas with fire danger, or using snowmobiles in some protected national parks. The decision to ban something recreational involves weighing a bunch of factors including the impact of the thing, and whether there are equivalent less-impactful alternatives. So no, the fact that it's a cruise is not an irrelevant detail, it gets considered along with other factors.
            • stickfigure 1 hour ago
              Rubbish.

              Lead bullets directly put lead in the environment, something we want to prohibit. Fireworks directly cause fires, something we want to prohibit.

              Cruises don't directly cause pollution. If we want to cut down on sulphur emissions, we can directly ban that, and let the cruise industry adapt.

              Banning the activity stinks of "my hobbies are better than your hobbies". Cruises are not my cup of tea either, but it's not my place to judge how other people want to experience leisure. Just wait until you hear about all the gasoline I "waste" on frivolous motorcycle adventures.

          • trashb 3 hours ago

              > If your problem is polluting, shouldn't you ban polluting then?
            
            Wouldn't that be great, I think the governments around the world seem to be moving in that direction (where feasible). Let's start with the biggest polluters that have the least societal value. I think you will reach cruise ships quite quickly in that list.

            Why don't you explain what's so special about cruises morally that we should keep them even though they are huge polluters and riddled with other problems?

            Because even though there is a clear alternative (go to a hotel). Why Do you need to be on a hotel on the sea with 6500 other passengers so bad that it warrants destroying the planet?

        • greatvaluebrand 2 hours ago
          Many of the worst practices from, say, the early 20th century are already banned. the goalpost just keeps moving to higher standards. I suppose that’s a sign of progress overall, but I think it’s worth being honest that environmental quality regulation is a treadmill and there is no end state or criteria for success. There will always be another crisis.
        • jazzyjackson 3 hours ago
          But all international cargo is in the same category of pollution. Is Temu necessary for life? We could cut a lot of pollution by banning international trade.
          • trashb 3 hours ago
            Yes and no, on a ship per ship basis cruise ships are far more polluting than their cargo counterparts. Cargo ships are not as simple to ban outright.

            I do however additionally think that we should have far stricter regulations regarding what can be shipped by sea because of pollution, for example the global bottled water industry.

            https://www.theguardian.com/sustainable-business/2015/jul/09...

      • samwiseg 4 hours ago
        Slippery slope argument. The pollution of cruises is totally egregious. There is no line that need to be drawn.
        • marky1991 4 hours ago
          Out of curiosity, what do you like to do for fun?
          • samwiseg 4 hours ago
            I like biking and birding and cooking. Sure all of it has a carbon impact. I travel to a different country for fun about once a year. That’s not necessary. But cruises are a crazy outlier in terms of pollution per person especially wrt utility/benefit to society
            • marky1991 4 hours ago
              Here, you're making a utilitarian argument. But presumably for people that go on cruises, they get a lot of utility by going, they pay a lot of money to do it. On what basis are you judging the costs and benefits here?

              I'm not aware of the details of this, what are the actual costs of sulfur oxide in the air?

              And as always with utilitarian arguments, why is your evaluation function special?

              If we were to just accept that "sulfur oxide is bad", then why wouldn't the obvious answer be "ban burning high sulfur gas", not "ban cruises"?

      • marky1991 4 hours ago
        Said another way, happiness itself is completely optional.

        Who are you to decide what kinds of pursuits of happiness are prudent and reasonable and which are excessively wasteful and must be banned?

        • bigbuppo 3 hours ago
          Cocaine makes people happy and that's banned.
    • itake 2 hours ago
      You're probably correct... but how does a cruise ship's impact compare to alternatives like flying or driving between those destinations?
      • ImJasonH 2 hours ago
        Given that a lot of cruise ships leave from a port and come back to that same port, I'd say their impact is infinity times more than a flight or drive between the points.
        • paulddraper 49 minutes ago
          To any normal human, this would obviously be a comparison of traveling to the same destinations and then returning.
        • IAmBroom 2 hours ago
          So a round-trip to the grocery store puts no mileage on your car?
    • geye1234 4 hours ago
      > To me the fact that cruise ships are still operating proves that most governments are not interested in actually improving climate pollution.

      The fact that WFH is not being strongly encouraged, or even mandated where possible, is what convinced me governments aren't serious. There was an excuse before 2020, there isn't now.

    • aeternum 4 hours ago
      I also don't see why sports are allowed, I don't like to watch sports and stadiums take up a lot of space, generate tons of trash, give players brain injuries, and worst of all waste people's time. I say ban them.

      I also don't see why meatball subs are still allowed, the bread gets soggy, ground beef is bad for you and the environment. And they taste bad.

      • trashb 3 hours ago
        Sure I think we can consider those also. I like racing cars, I think that should also be up for discussion.

        However perhaps you are not familiar with the amount of pollution a cruise ship generates. Cruise ships are on such a different scale, therefore they should be considered a lot more seriously compared to your local sports event.

        We also allow fireworks for entertainment but not nuclear bombs.

    • mzajc 4 hours ago
      > To me it seems like the lowest hanging fruit in the climate disaster.

      At least some very rich people get a kick out of it. Here's a better one: the entire EU parliament has to move to Strasbourg and then back to Brussels monthly.[0] The MEPs don't like it, it costs a bunch and burns a lot of avgas, and the official rationale for mandating this madness is that "that's how we've always done it."[1]

      None of this is to say that cruises should continue to be allowed, but some fruit is practically touching the ground by this point.

      [0]: https://www.politico.eu/article/france-cancelling-european-p...

      [1]: https://www.europarl.europa.eu/news/en/faq/3/why-does-parlia...

    • MrBuddyCasino 5 hours ago
      [flagged]
      • samwiseg 4 hours ago
        Least selfish and ignorant cruise goer
      • trashb 4 hours ago
        No need for name calling.

        Do you have an argument why amusement/entertainment isn't excess/optional and shouldn't be considered to be banned for the benefit of the planet?

        • panzagl 4 hours ago
          Is a national park excess/optional? What is it's purpose other than amusement/entertainment?
          • trashb 4 hours ago
            You can literally put this comment into gemini and get the answer but i'll summarize it here for you:

              - Nature and wildlife conservation
              - Cultural and historical preservation
              - Scientific Research and public education
              - Climate Regulation
              - Regulate water flow, prevent soil erosion and supply clean drinking water 
              - Flood, Wildfire and Storm Protection
            • jazzyjackson 3 hours ago
              If you couldn’t come up with this yourself and went to a chatbot for help you’re already cooked, and, encouraging an ecologically damaging use of energy via AI

              Banning data centers is actually pretty popular among democrats so careful what you wish for, banning unnecessary sources of entertainment

              • trashb 3 hours ago
                Obviously responding to a bait comment. "put this comment into gemini" can be read in the same sarcastic manner as "let me google that for you".

                If you replace "national park" with "cruise ship" and similar reasons can not be found.

                  > Banning data centers is actually pretty popular among democrats so careful what you wish for, banning unnecessary sources of entertainment
                
                Perhaps that wouldn't be so bad from a pollution standpoint now would it?

                No need to pull in political association by mentioning democrats.

                • panzagl 1 hour ago
                  None of this comes to anything other than you wanting to condescend to people who don't like what you like. Continue to do so, then act surprised the next time the majority of people decide they're tired of being treated like they have no value and vote in someone who promises to line the intelligentsia up against a wall.
                • jazzyjackson 42 minutes ago
                  I’m just rolling my eyes that you’ve outsourced your argumentation to a chatbot.

                  Political association or not I was only referring to the incoming administration having their own ideas about what is and isn’t necessary and worth polluting over. AI may not come out ahead of cruise ships unless they really do put the average American out of work.

  • nehal3m 10 hours ago
    One of the easiest wins would be outlawing burning bunker fuel for recreational purposes, would it not? I'm not posing this as absolute truth but I don't see any direct limitations to personal freedoms. Let cruise operators burn something less ridiculously dirty and if that prices cruising out of the market, so be it.
    • wouldbecouldbe 7 hours ago
      Isn't it more effective to just legislate ships to only allow docking in EU ports if they have certain filters on their engines? Like they did with cars
    • wittjeff 9 hours ago
      They're not going to put it back in the ground or pour it raw into the ocean. When supply increases (no cruise ships), the price falls, and then it becomes more economical for freight carriers to burn it faster and less efficiently.
      • mattlondon 7 hours ago
        I think just don't let anyone burn it?

        If just 47 ships are more polluting by an order of magnitude than all the cars in Europe, I can only imagine how much is coming out of the container ships which I presume dwarf the number of cruise ships

        • BenjiWiebe 7 hours ago
          Isn't it more that European cars emit extremely small amounts of sulfur?

          I'd expect the 47 ships' CO2 output wouldn't be more than all cars in Europe.

          • jerlam 3 hours ago
            Especially now in 2026, as Europeans have adopted EVs that probably don't emit sulfur. But then a correct comparison would need to take into account how clean the power is generated, battery production, etc. And the previous comparison would also need to take into account the outputs of fuel production, etc.
        • dnemmers 7 hours ago
          So what do you do with the leftovers of oil production...??
          • spockz 7 hours ago
            Find a way to store it properly or convert it into higher quality things. It’s not being done now because it is easier and cheaper to just dump it into ships.
          • bluGill 7 hours ago
            Sulfur has industrial uses. It isn't cost competitive to extract sulfur from oil, but if you have to extract it anyway you will sell the extracted sulfur to get something from your efforts.
          • makapuf 7 hours ago
            Question being, where do you prefer to put it? In the ground or in the lungs of people? Sure, putting it in lungs would be cheaper, but so would asbestos.
          • another_bear 7 hours ago
            Who cares? If I make too many park benches I don't get just off-load them because I made too much.
        • excannuk 54 minutes ago
          [dead]
      • gwbas1c 6 hours ago
        Does it require additional treatment in the refinery (so Sulphur is removed from the fuel and disposed appropriately?)
      • NewJazz 6 hours ago
        This implies that demand for freight shipping is highly elastic, which is a big claim.
        • wittjeff 2 hours ago
          Interesting rabbit hole. It turns out the demand for bulk transit fuel is quite inelastic but they have some flexibility in which fuel types to use, and that is made more complex by the uneven use of scrubbers. At particularly low prices, refineries can break bunker oil down further into diesel, Marine Gas Oil, etc. which is new to me. There are some studies out there looking at the impact of Covid on demand for a conveniently contained period. But anyway it does make me wonder what residual might be left over, including pollutants, if all HFO were required to be refined to the maximum extent possible.
    • andyferris 10 hours ago
      International maritime law falls outside any one jurisdiction. Generally we don’t have a system to penalise global externalities…
      • patrickmcnamara 10 hours ago
        Just make it illegal to make port? I feel like this is super easy.
        • lesuorac 8 hours ago
          Maybe not bunker fuel (i forget all the names).

          But it is illegal to port with low quality fuel and ships will be setup to run on multiple grades and use the less expensive grade allowed for where they are.

          Ex. The Dali that hit the bridge awhile go in Baltimore had its “backup” system setup with the lower quality (and illegal to use in us waters) and it switched to that during it’s electrical issues.

        • martinjc 9 hours ago
          In that case they will dump it at sea, and then use a cleaner fuel to dock.
          • cocoto 8 hours ago
            Most of these big ships (at least container ships as far as I know) already use different fuels: cleaner fuels where it’s mandatory (close to borders) and cheaper/dirtier fuels on big seas.
          • patrickmcnamara 9 hours ago
            Yep. That is the one completely unstoppable and unavoidable loophole. It would be completely impossible to prosecute for this. It's too bad.
            • ehnto 8 hours ago
              You are being sarcastic but there would be no shortage of operators and countries willing to look the other way.

              Mining is another heavy industry with a lot of regulations and people work around things like that, workers are just as unwilling and uncaring to fulfil regulatory requirements that make their lives harder. Unfathomable tonnes of waste get discarded wherever convenient underground, so long as the boss doesn't hear about it, he doesn't ask questions.

              That's without having access to a vast ocean of international waters.

              • patrickmcnamara 5 hours ago
                > there would be no shortage of operators and countries willing to look the other way.

                Yeah, but if the EU and US could agree to this, and also put it in their trade agreements, that's a pretty good start. It doesn't need to be solved everywhere.

              • lesuorac 8 hours ago
                Porting is also optional in some cases. You could do ship-ship transfers and never port.
                • nehal3m 8 hours ago
                  On a cruise? Then what's the point?
                  • bluGill 7 hours ago
                    It isn't uncommon to have to transfer to a smaller boat on a cruise ship to get to land. Many popular ports don't have enough docking space for all the ships that stop there so some ships already are anchoring out at sea. Passengers hate this - the transfer takes time and messes with their schedule, but it is somewhat common.
                  • lesuorac 8 hours ago
                    Do you care that much if you walk onto a cruise ship or take a ferry to a ship?

                    They go to minor lengths to avoid cabotage rules so seems reasonable they’d add other workarounds.

              • conception 5 hours ago
                It’s hilarious that Apple can get suppliers to bend the knee on environmental action but people think the United States Government has no recourse to force ships to an environmental standard.

                “All passenger ships that sell berths for US citizens must comply with X or have their ships impounded/fines/taxes/etc.”

                Get the EU on board as well and the problem is solved. They don’t have to patch every regulatory hole just make it more expensive than complying.

                • patrickmcnamara 1 hour ago
                  It's because people want to be contrarian and ridiculous. People pretend that the law is some sort of perfect software contract and that it accepts a bunch of gotchas. It is loosely defined, and can be strongly enforced.
          • __MatrixMan__ 6 hours ago
            Sooner or later some large country with a lot of land near the equator is gonna have enough climate related problems that they start solving that particular problem with sniffer drones and torpedoes.
      • nehal3m 9 hours ago
        True, but Carnival is headquartered in Florida. Surely that means something in a legal sense.
        • timdiggerm 9 hours ago
          Yeah, it means they can do pretty much whatever they want
        • robertlagrant 9 hours ago
          Then they'll headquarter elsewhere or be out-competed by someone else who is.
          • nehal3m 9 hours ago
            So that means no.
      • chinathrow 9 hours ago
        Can't dock with that fuel on board. Problem solved.
    • heresie-dabord 9 hours ago
      > One of the easiest wins would be outlawing burning bunker fuel

      Democratically-voted environmental policy has not found such wins to be "easy". The "rule of law" has lost every battle against the tourism industry and transnational petroleum.

      • nehal3m 9 hours ago
        I'd have defined 'easy' as the largest environmental win versus the fewest required regulations, but I take your point. Fighting economic interests for survival is hard as it turns out.
    • tito 9 hours ago
      Yes this seems sensible. There’s plenty of regulations for ships. See the IMO 2020 policy around lowering sulfur dioxide emissions from shipping fuels.
    • mavhc 9 hours ago
      Tax all fuel the cost to clean up the pollution it causes, side effects include people inventing cleaner fuels and cheaper ways to clean up pollution
    • VoodooJuJu 8 hours ago
      [dead]
    • koolba 9 hours ago
      > One of the easiest wins would be outlawing burning bunker fuel for recreational purposes

      I’m hardly an advocate for cruises (entire concept is disgusting and I think they’re a cholera time bomb…), but why is shuttling sneakers from around the planet more important than shuttling humans?

      • patrickmcnamara 9 hours ago
        Absurd straw-man question. There are many, many important things shipped by container. Shuttling drunk boomers around is not important.
        • pluralmonad 9 hours ago
          What proportion of those containers are important things? Isn't a lot of it plastic on its way to the landfill with a brief stop in someone's house? I think you'd have a difficult time arguing importance/need while flipping through the majority of Amazon's catalog.
          • Ekaros 9 hours ago
            So why not outright ban them? Only allow useful items. That would entirely remove need of transportation and even save resources if they would then not be manufactured at home.
            • lostlogin 9 hours ago
              You can’t see how defining ‘useful’ might be hard?

              I generally side against those advocating for ‘freedoms’ when it ends up being a defence of shitty behaviour. However, I don’t love the idea of governments banning various types of business based on how ‘useful’ governments think the business is.

              • nehal3m 9 hours ago
                Governments already regulate recreational versus medicinal use of drugs for example, which if you ask me is arbitrary moral regulation. Why not do the same when it severely affects the climate, air quality and the future of our species? (I mean it's probably economic interests, but still, inconsistency is already part and parcel of governance)
                • lucaspm98 8 hours ago
                  Your example of moral judgment of recreational versus medicinal drugs has a poor track record, at best.
          • patrickmcnamara 5 hours ago
            Not everything has to be solved at the exact same time.
        • f6v 9 hours ago
          > Absurd straw-man question

          It's because the whole discussion is absurd. I can come up with a thousand things that are not important and detrimental to humanity. You just have a tiny problem of convincing hundreds of millions of people to give up their hobbies.

          • trashb 5 hours ago
            A few million giving up their hobby (~40 million people take sea cruises yearly) for the benefit of literally the whole planet (~8.3 billion) is not a difficult choice in my opinion.

            That is 0.48% of the population of the earth.

            Can you give me 1 reason why cruises should not be shut down? I can do it for container shipping, important things are shipped that we need for modern society to function.

            • BenjiWiebe 3 hours ago
              And according to Gemini, cruise ships cumulatively account for about 0.2% of CO2 emissions. Remember this article is about one specific type of emission.
        • jstanley 9 hours ago
          Absurd straw-man answer. There are many, many important people shipped by cruise liner.
        • sdoering 8 hours ago
          > Shuttling drunk boomers

          Talking about straw-man arguments.

  • tptacek 4 hours ago
    Cruises are horrible and all, but is this a super meaningful comparison? Are cars a primary source of SOx pollution? This is a very specific comparison, which makes me wary.
  • throw0101c 5 hours ago
    As noted, this is from 2019. The International Maritime Organization put restrictions on the sulphur content in emissions starting 2020-01-01:

    * https://www.imo.org/en/mediacentre/hottopics/pages/sulphur-2...

    * https://www.cmacgm-group.com/en/low-sulphur-imo-2020-regulat...

    Is this particular issue (sulphur) still an issue?

    • dodger-dog 3 hours ago
      Sulfur was never the issue—that is the moral of the story.
  • ben_w 10 hours ago
    Negatives: acid rain

    Positives: seeds cloud formation in the right way to cool, mitigating some of the effects of the greenhouse gasses.

    https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Stratospheric_aerosol_injectio...

    • combobyte 10 hours ago
      The problem is that the majority of that acid rain falls into the Atlantic ocean, accelerating ocean acidification. The lower the pH of the oceans, the harder it is for CO2 to remained dissolved in ocean water, so more of it goes into the atmosphere.

      So S02 cloud seeding will produce cooling to a point... but eventually you hit a tipping point where the amount of trapped carbon released from the oceans overwhelms any cooling effect. It's also worth noting that the cooling effectiveness maxes out at 100% cloud cover, but that sulfuric acid concentrations in the ocean can continue to grow without a strict upper bound.

      • ben_w 9 hours ago
        Problems abound in many regards.

        But climate change is already here, and already causing problems.

        I don't know if this is metaphorically "trying to treat cancer with a medical plaster", or "a tourniquet to stop you bleeding out of the stump where your foot used to be": former in the sense of it's pointless, latter in the sense that leaving it on too long and doing nothing else will give you gangrene, but it also gives you long enough that you get a chance to worry about and fix such things.

        • combobyte 11 minutes ago
          I think aerosols will probably be an import part of climate mitigation strategies going forward, but S02 ain't it. Before we start spraying stuff into the atmosphere we need find/engineer aerosols that are:

          1) non-toxic

          2) biodegradable

          3) have a very short half life in the atmosphere so if our models are wrong they won't hang around for centuries and start a new ice age

      • squidmaster 9 hours ago
        [dead]
    • actionfromafar 10 hours ago
      I wonder how much the recent temperature spikes are because of the container ships not adding as much sulphur as they used to.
      • kzrdude 9 hours ago
        Here is a climate model based answer, where they say that

        > The warming effect is consistent with the recent observed strong warming in 2023 and expected to make the 2020 s anomalously warm. The forcing is equivalent in magnitude to 80% of the measured increase in planetary heat uptake since 2020.

        https://www.nature.com/articles/s43247-024-01442-3

      • himata4113 10 hours ago
        That wave has already passed and it has actually returned to normal.
      • busssard 10 hours ago
        that forcing is considered in some climate models and afaik the rise is noticable and compares well to the models.

        dont ask me for the source please o_o i dont know anymore when i read that, was a couple years back

        • tito 9 hours ago
          [dead]
  • everdrive 8 hours ago
    Carnival Cruises feel like they're up there with golf courses for some of the worst resource management practiced today. I can't think of anything worse than being trapped on a cruise ship.
    • Jcampuzano2 7 hours ago
      I went on a cruise as a teenager with my parents that they booked for us. Even as a child it was fun for all of maybe 24 hours. The rest of the time was excruciatingly boring and practically everything we did on board could have been done cheaper and more efficiently on land.

      I definitely think that cruises are probably up there in the top ten, if not the top five, of the most wasteful recreational activities available to most people on Earth.

      I have some friends who regularly go on cruises and I always just wonder: why not just go to the beach? It's basically the exact same thing, or book out a hotel that's close to the beach. Hell half of Miami basically recreates everything a cruise ship has but on land.

      • gosub100 7 hours ago
        And enshittification has hit the industry hard. They also pull the foreign worker scam where they charge American prices but pay their workers according to developing nation wages. Hmm I wonder why they don't pay the captain or senior management those wages?
    • throwaway2037 7 hours ago
      My hot take: I think the best designed airports are surrounded by golf courses. This keeps a buffer around the airport, and provides a land source future expansion.

      Also, if golf courses were converted into sports fields, would you feel similar?

      • lukas099 6 hours ago
        Most sports fields are far, far more efficient in terms of area of land used per person entertained.
      • everdrive 7 hours ago
        There are better and worse ways to do it for sure. Usually from what I can tell, airports are already surrounded by hotels and gas stations and highways and such. There doesn't seem to be a bunch of untapped land available for golf course optimization.

        My big problem with golf courses are the huge amount of area required for something which is relatively niche. Even sports I don't particularly like, such as baseball or football are much, much more popular and have tons of spectators, which makes their land use feel a bit more valuable. The other problem would be water usage and herbicide usage. All that water and herbicide just so a tiny portion of the population can play golf more easily. Feels like a total waste.

      • fenwick67 7 hours ago
        A golf course is a sports field
    • BeFlatXIII 5 hours ago
      How do they compare to Royal Caribbean, Disney, or Celebrity?

      I had a friend who is a fan of cruise ships call Carnival the "Section 8 cruise ship."

  • dang 8 hours ago
    Discussed at the time:

    Carnival Cruises emits ten times more sulphur oxide than all of Europe’s cars - https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=20203006 - June 2019 (158 comments)

  • sct202 7 hours ago
    The cruise industry has started to move towards liquified natural gas powered ships which emit very little sulfur oxide just due to natural gas having almost no sulfur. Carnival has 11 LNG ships out of its fleet of 90 so there is some progress for this specific pollutant.
  • tpm 9 hours ago
    This article is from 2019, before the 2020' IMO limits came into power.

    https://www.cnbc.com/2019/07/15/oil-imo-2020-marks-the-bigge...

  • passwordoops 9 hours ago
    And what's changed in the 7 years since this was last posted?
    • jon-wood 9 hours ago
      One small thing that's changed is that Southampton's cruise ship terminal now has shore power for docked ships, which means that they don't have to run their engines while docked just to keep the lights on. Obviously that doesn't help when at sea, but as a local resident I'm grateful for it.

      https://www.abports.co.uk/news-and-media/latest-news/2022/sh...

      • alpineman 8 hours ago
        You shouldn't have to be grateful for having clean(er) air and water. It's your right and you should demand it.
  • timbit42 7 hours ago
    Europe has a lot more hybrids and EVs now. It's probably more than ten times today.
  • kakacik 10 hours ago
    Same goes for all big ships with containers, and this is well known for 2+ decades. Big ships simply have engines designed to take the cheapest, shittiest fuel and somehow cca burn it to keep costs per km as low as possible.
    • GuB-42 10 hours ago
      I think people are just more tolerant when it is container ships, because modern civilization depends on them. Make shipping more expensive and everything becomes more expensive. And we have to find some use for that shitty fuel anyways.

      Cruses are pure luxury, we can do without them, it is seen as entertainment for the rich at the expense of everyone else, people usually don't take kindly of that.

      Another difference is that cruse ships tend to end up in tourist places for everyone to see and smell, while container ships are in commercial ports, usually further away from where people tend to hang out.

      • throwaway2037 7 hours ago

            > it is seen as entertainment for the rich at the expense of everyone else
        
        This is a weird take, and certainly untrue in the US where most cruises are squarely aimed at the middle class.
      • Telemakhos 9 hours ago
        Are cruises even considered “luxurious” anymore? I don’t know any billionaires, but my better-off friends don’t cruise. Meanwhile the internet is full of clips of rowdy brawls between low socio-economic status individuals on Carnival ships. It seems like the pandemic drove the nail in the coffin of luxury cruises.
        • Jcampuzano2 7 hours ago
          Some are but Carnival definitely isn't. It's basically like booking a two-star hotel that just happens to float over the ocean and have nearby entertainment.

          You could get the exact same experience by booking a hotel at practically every tourist beach town you can think of.

        • quietsegfault 9 hours ago
          Carnival isn’t a luxury line. There are many luxury cruise lines out there, on boats that are much smaller than the mega cruise ships.
    • seanhunter 10 hours ago
      It’s called “bunker fuel” or heavy fuel oil and it’s literally the heaviest, grossest bits of crude oil after you have distilled off anything that you possibly can. It’s thick, viscous and very sour (high in sulphur) and of course burns very inefficiently leading to lots of pollution. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Heavy_fuel_oil#Heavy_fuel_oil_...
      • kyykky 10 hours ago
        Yeah. Those ships using HFO have tanks that must be heated in order to keep the stuff liquid enough to not get stuck into their pipes.

        Then IMO made some rules that there cannot be so much emissions (into air) and, as a consequence, the ships started using open loop seawater scrubbers which are essentially washing the exhaust gas and emitting all that same crap directly into the sea. Great benefit.

    • Steve44 9 hours ago
      I've been fascinated by the NO2 Air Quality maps on Windy. You can see the concentration in the The Strait of Malacca going straight to Sri Lanka and then where it splits up to go to the Persian Gulf and the other line to Suez.

      There are other concentrations, such as around Turkey ( a major manufacturing country ) and then through the pinch-point of Gibraltar.

      https://www.windy.com/-Menu/menu?cams,no2,9.998,64.187,4

      It also gives and indication of where a lot of the global manufacturing is based!

  • BeFlatXIII 5 hours ago
    How do they compare to Royal Caribbean or Disney?
    • bob1029 5 hours ago
      Likely identical? I don't think hydrodynamics is too concerned with the company that owns the vessel.
  • jeremyjh 9 hours ago
    Needs 2019 in the title.
  • jordemort 8 hours ago
    then sink them
  • coryfklein 4 hours ago
    Big news! When you burn dirty fuel you put pollutants in the air. Cars don't emit sulphur oxide because the fuel they burn is much more regulated.

    Maybe it is a hit piece on Carnival? Because the entire cruise industry emits a whopping 0.8% of the sulphur dioxide that the shipping industry itself does [0].

    [0] Fourth International Maritime Organization Greenhouse Gas Study 2020, page 11 figure 9, https://wwwcdn.imo.org/localresources/en/OurWork/Environment...

  • JensenTorp 8 hours ago
    This article was widely mocked for its false equivalence when it was published years ago. Surprised to see its corpse being dug-up on HackerNews.
  • Towaway69 5 hours ago
    Just yesterday i had this idea for a far side comic where a cruise ship sails past a cow transport ship and the cows wave to the humans.

    Perhaps we should also be thinking about non-human cruise ships or do they magically pollute less because they transport the worlds future burgers?

  • nsoam 10 hours ago
    It’s old and rich people who use these, so don’t worry, nothing will happen to them.

    Cars used by the poor to get to their jobs, on the other hand…

    • helsinkiandrew 10 hours ago
      > It’s old and rich people who use these

      Increasingly the younger are going:

      > Young travelers, especially those aged 21 to 39, are seeing those social media videos and responding with an eager curiosity for cruises. Cruise Lines International Association (CLIA) reports that Millennials (22%) and Gen Z (14%) now make up roughly 36% of all cruise passengers. Jason Liberty, president and CEO of Royal Caribbean Group, says about half of Royal Caribbean’s guests are now Millennials or younger (including those under age 20).

      https://cruising.org/news/new-wave-cruisers-how-millennials-...

      • eterm 9 hours ago
        > Young travelers, especially those aged 21 to 39

        You know you're in a messed up state when 39 year olds are described as "Young travellers".

        Many Millennials are over 40 too, lumping them in as "young travellers" and pretending it's an achievement to get 22% of your clientele from that demographic just demonstrates how aged the cruising demographic really is.

        • brazukadev 8 hours ago
          for the bad and the good, 39 years now is considered quite young, one of the reasons is because the generation older than them are still active and are way more resourceful.
    • flexagoon 9 hours ago
      Not all cruises are luxury cruises. They're often less expensive than a good hotel.
    • CGMthrowaway 8 hours ago
      15-20% of a cruise lines opex is labor... for the crew... who are universally working class... as many as 2000 jobs per ship on the biggest ships.

      It's not only rich people on these ships. In fact the richer the ship the more poor people are on it.

    • drbscl 10 hours ago
      > Carnival Cruises

      > rich people

      I don't think you understand their target demographic

      • fuzzfactor 7 hours ago
        Exactly. Plenty rich people have their own single-family yachts which are usually even less-efficient fuel-wise.

        Cruises are more like the "affordable-living" option for the less-privileged who want to sail the sea. Sometimes just one time before they die.

    • hagbard_c 10 hours ago
      > Cars used by the poor to get to their jobs

      Imagine saying something like this without realising the silliness of that statement.

      Those who have cars and jobs and can afford to use the former to get to the latter aren't poor, by definition. Words have meaning, 'poor' means having little money and/or few possessions which tends to exclude those who have cars and jobs. Poor is not the same as 'lower class', 'not well to do', 'not affluent' or any such construct. Many countries have official 'poverty thresholds' which are closer to 'not well to do' than 'actual poverty', e.g. in the UK households are considered to be below the poverty line if their income is below 60% of the median household income after housing costs for that year [1]. That is not poverty, it is 'not well to do'. The international poverty line lies somewhere around $1.90 a day at 2011 international prices [2]. The former 'poverty' means those people can't afford to go on a foreign holiday, the latter often means they can't eat other than from garbage heaps.

      Words have meaning.

      [1] https://trustforlondon.org.uk/data/poverty-thresholds/

      [2] https://www.who.int/data/nutrition/nlis/info/population-belo...

      • graemep 9 hours ago
        The use of "poor" hear is clearly relative to the country, not the international poverty line. You also need to take cost of living into account. You are somewhat right about the UK poverty line numbers, but there are people a lot worse of than that.

        I think it is not silly for Americans. Minimum wage varies a lot by state and in some it a lot lower than the UK. Old cars are cheaper (because they do not need to meet standards like the MOT to stay on the road), petrol is cheaper and the need for a car is greater.

        • graemep 7 hours ago
          Also the UK poverty line is significantly worse off than "can't afford to go on a foreign holiday". If you are a single person with £200/week after housing costs (and I assume after all taxes) a big chunk of that will go on utilities, food and household essentials.
      • soon_to_be_sb 9 hours ago
        >Words have meaning.

        Context matters though. Here it is clear "poor" is in comparison to people going on cruises...

      • throwdown7653 9 hours ago
        Contrasted against "the rich", the rest are the poor.

        Words have meaning in various ways, most often related to the other words they are used with.

        Also. there are plenty of people below the poverty line that own cars... perhaps not specifically using the standard of the international poverty line.

        But, if you choose not to understand, you can find meaninglessness in anything I suppose.

        Good day

  • nottorp 9 hours ago
    > Cruise giant - Carnival Corporation - emits 10 times more air pollution than all of Europe’s cars – study

    Seriously? How much "other pollution" do "all of Europe's cars" emit, besides the sulphur oxide?

  • bethekidyouwant 6 hours ago
    Yes, a thing that does have sulfur (heavy fuel oil) emits more than a thing that doesn't have sulfur (gas) . even if one is not the same size as the other.
  • guywithahat 7 hours ago
    *because cars don’t produce meaningful amounts of sulfur oxide

    This wasn’t worth digging up from 6 years ago.

  • t1234s 2 hours ago
    Is this mostly from the smell of the disgusting people they allow on their ships?
  • swolios 4 hours ago
    Wait till you see how bad cargo ships and oil tankers pollute. All these ships use bunker fuel.
  • dark-star 1 hour ago
    and yet, people in Europe still genuinely believe that by driving electric vehicles, they are saving the planet :-D
  • titzer 6 hours ago
    But it's run by billionaires, so we let them do it.
  • mcjenkisns 7 hours ago
    Now imagine ships shipping Chinese crap around the world
  • excannuk 1 hour ago
    [dead]
  • afh1 9 hours ago
    And China burns more coal than the rest of the _world_ combined, but that doesn't get attention here because sanctions on China would make everything so expensive for Europeans that it would show they don't _really_ care about the environment.
    • myrmidon 7 hours ago
      It does get mentioned regularly.

      But an important thing to consider is that coal in China also completely fills the typical role of gas for electrical generation (=> dispatchable source). For a somewhat fair comparison it's thus sensible to group coal+gas, and you'll find plenty of wealthy western countries that are similarly overreliant on fossils in that metric (yes gas is less harmful, but nations don't get to pick which fossils are available to them).

      But despite this, China is pretty close to EU per capita emission and significantly lower than the US. Cumulative emissions are also much lower than either, despite representing a larger population than both of those combined.

      • devsda 5 hours ago
        On top of that, if we trace back to the tail end of the beneficiaries of that carbon, I suspect it lands on the side where the consumption is considered borderline wasteful by the rest of the world standards.
    • TeMPOraL 7 hours ago
      If you exclude the places that are basically a rounding error in this, then China is also 1/3 of the population in-scope, which suddenly doesn't sound as absurd.
    • cc81 7 hours ago
      Why would you sanction China for that? The US is still ahead per capita
    • brazukadev 8 hours ago
      One think nobody can't deny is that China is investing heavily on the alternatives, more than any country ever.
      • Asmod4n 8 hours ago
        In around 10-15 years they could stop using coal when the trend for solar and wind continues like it does.

        What gets shipped in around 2-3 years and what’s being done in research looks very promising

        • ben_w 5 hours ago
          > In around 10-15 years they could stop using coal when the trend for solar and wind continues like it does.

          Much faster than that. Even worldwide, the trend on each of those by itself puts PV above 100% of all current global electricity supply by the early 2030s and wind by the end of the 2030s.

          Combined, and considering what hydro and nuclear already exists, we could easily anticipate that on top of covering all electrical demand, in ten years everything has been electrified.

        • myrmidon 7 hours ago
          Agree. And their total, absolute coal use looks like it's already plateauing, with new plants often just replacing older ones and being run at lower capacity factor; its fractional share in electricity production is decreasing sharply (because of still growing demand).

          Spain, for comparison, took over 20 years to get their coal use down from ~40% but they had much worse renewable options back then and needed to rely on gas a lot.

  • bozdemir 8 hours ago
    Pollution, carbon footprint and global warming regulations are always pushed to working class people.
  • funkytownjoe 7 hours ago
    Now imagine all those Chinese cargo ships shipping cargo around the world.